The Clean Volume Duo

I picked the black shade for everyday wear and it’s become my morning go-to—one coat gives enough volume without clumping, and the wand is easy to control even on my lower lashes. The set itself is nice because you get a backup tube, which I’ve already needed.

This mascara layers on so smoothly without clumping, even after three coats, and it holds my lashes up all day without flaking. The set is a nice way to try the clean formula, and I've already worn it through a humid commute with zero smudging.

I was skeptical about a clean mascara actually holding a curl, but this duo's formula layers beautifully without clumping and washes off easily with just warm water. The shade choice is a nice bonus too, since I can grab a softer brown for workdays and save the black for nights out.